Skip to main content

Communication between the Genders: Relational vs. Hierarchical Viewpoints

Thought:


"However, each one of you also must love his wife as he loves himself, and the wife must respect her husband."

 Ephesians 5:33

In order to understand how common miscommunications occur between men and women, it is important to appreciate how each gender views the world. It is natural for each of us to believe that our perspective is universal, but one's gender tremendously impacts thinking style.

Researcher/author Deborah Tannen has done interesting work examining sociolinguistic differences between the sexes. In her book, You Just Don't Understand, she explains that the male worldview is hierarchical whereas the female's is relational. These perspectives are radically different from each other.

Men's communication tends to establish and manage their standing with those around them. In other words, they see the world in terms of who has greater prestige or respect than themselves and who does not. In this perspective there are winners and losers, and each man works to win. It is not surprising that most male establishments or businesses have a management style that reflect this worldview.  Many of these organizations have a hierarchical system that is comprised of a president, then, department heads, and finally, co-workers.

The male hierarchical social perspective tends to make men sensitive to feeling blame since protecting their standing with others is very important. They dislike apologizing, as this would be taking a "one-down" position, and their communication style usually is very literal and direct. Men generally don't tend to each other's feelings, but rather talk about numbers, tangible details, and day-to-day activities.

Women, on the other hand, see the world in terms of social connections. They are aware of who they have relationships with and who they don't. Because of this style, women are concerned with maintaining affiliation with others.  They are careful not to hurt another's feelings. Their communication habits reflect this value and, therefore, are often indirect, abstract, and qualitative. Women tend to talk about relationships, such as, who is dating whom, the latest neighborhood gossip, or working through social difficulties. They often monitor each other's reactions to stay in good graces with each other and apologize easily in order to maintain social connections.

Due to these stark differences, it is easy to see how communication mishaps occur. Women hint at issues and then wonder why their boyfriends or spouses don't catch on.  They long to have their male loved one understand their gentle indirect reminders and feel hurt when he isn't a mind-reader. Apologies are difficult for men leaving the women in their lives feeling that their emotional pain is devalued. God had it right when he gave instructions for a good marriage (Ephesians 5:33). In Paul's letter, wives are encouraged to respect their husbands (i.e. understand and support the husband's standing), and men are instructed to love their wives (or tend to the relationship). If both parties could become aware of the way that the opposite gender sees and communicates about life, then fewer misunderstandings are likely to occur.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Narcissism: Understanding the Effects of Narcissistic Parenting

Since Freud, researchers have studied various environmental effects on maturing personalities, and it has been well documented that parenting styles are profoundly involved in the shaping of children’s developing psyches. It is hard enough working with a narcissistic boss or living with a narcissistic spouse, but being raised by narcissistic parents has several serious emotional consequences. What are some of these effects? Dr. Paul Meier in his book, You Might Be a Narcissist If . . . How to Identify Narcissism in Ourselves and Others and what We Can Do About It , identifies four consequences of narcissistic parenting. They are: 1) the  development of a false self; 2) the desire to behave with perfectionism; 3) chronic habits of passivity; and 4) increased vulnerability to addictive behaviors. The Development of a False Self Since narcissistic parents unconsciously need others to help soothe their fragile sense of self, they naturally turn to any available relationsh...

Antisocial Personality Disorder Resource List

This is the final article in the series looking at Antisocial Personality Disorder. I plan to start a new series discussing various aspects of Depression in January 2013. Hope everyone has a wonderful, happy holiday season! Resource List Snakes in Suits: When Psychopaths go to Work by Paul Babiak, PhD & Robert D. Hare, PhD (2006) HarperCollins Publishers Not all individuals with Antisocial Personality Disorder (APD) are in prison, many are among us. They work and play alongside us. Babiak and Hare reveal the common ploys of psychopaths, especially in the corporate world. The authors provide detailed suggestions about how to screen for psychopaths in the interview process as well as how to protect the work environment from those whose main goals are to manipulate and exploit the workplace. This is an outstanding book for those in the business world who would like to become more aware of the subtle warning signs of psychopaths.   The Sociopa...

Borderline Personality Disorder: Characteristics and Development of BPD

I recently came across a YouTube clip from the fourth season of Bravo’s The Real Housewives of New Jersey . In this episode Teresa Guidice exploded in a fit of rage and flipped over a restaurant table. I don’t watch the show or know if any of these women have a psychological condition, but I was struck by Teresa’s display of impulsivity and disruptive behavior. The scene takes place at a very nice restaurant. Teresa is arguing with a friend. When the friend becomes insulting, Teresa responds with rage. She begins a tirade while pounding the table with her fist and finally flips the table over. Several men rush to her side. She shoves one away, but allows another to comfort her. She then calms down and they end their conversation with a kiss.  In a post interview Teresa seems unaware of the intensity of her emotional outburst. She doesn’t realize she shoved her male friend. She is also out of touch with her table guests’ reactions of shock and confusion...